Jump to content
 

Hornby Class 423 4-VEP


Adam1701D
 Share

Recommended Posts

There storage warehouse must be a long way away. I ordered mine Friday on the first hours and it still has not left yet!

My VEP is showing as despatched as of 25/02/15 so the van has arrived at the shop, yours should be on its way as well!

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

Ordered one yesterday eve along with a Blue Bill which "accidently fell in me basket" I'm already looking at using some spare Hornby DMU bogie steps as the short ones may come in usefull.

As for the guard irons I've already made one as me NSE unit lost one when I was doing the bogie mods to correct the assembly error. Roll on postie!

Link to post
Share on other sites

Mine arrived yesterday morning and is already run in and chipped. I have to agree with others that the "face" of the VEP looks better in blue/grey than it does in blue or NSE. There's no reason for it as the moulding is identical, it just does look better! Strange.

 

post-17811-0-82747200-1424944280.jpg

 

  • Like 7
Link to post
Share on other sites

Email from Kernow says mine has now been packed and is ready to start its long journey to Australia.

Nice photos Ron. They do highlight that the Hornby corner pillars are too wide. At the price, I can live with it until I get up the courage to do something better, but it does still annoy me just a little.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Mine arrived yesterday morning and is already run in and chipped. I have to agree with others that the "face" of the VEP looks better in blue/grey than it does in blue or NSE. There's no reason for it as the moulding is identical, it just does look better! Strange.

 

attachicon.gifmanorroad_130.jpg

It does look better...... Blue-Grey magic

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • RMweb Premium

It seems to be that Hornby's designers made the front door too narrow, but put the windows and pipe recess in the right place relative to the door leading to the gap between edge of body and windows/recess being too wide.

Link to post
Share on other sites

That porch effect with the connecting door being deeply recessed looks horrendous. That has to be one of the biggest gaffs with this model, but the blinkered seem to be ignoring it. The 4VEP is still a Dog!

 

Or some of us don't care because it's certainly much better than any attempt I could ever dream of doing with a kit. 

 

If you don't like a RTR model for whatever reason don't buy it. 

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

That porch effect with the connecting door being deeply recessed looks horrendous. That has to be one of the biggest gaffs with this model, but the blinkered seem to be ignoring it. The 4VEP is still a Dog!

 

Perhaps the "blinkered" remember when there was no Southern Region RTR (certainly no EMU stock) and are simply grateful now that there is. My attempts at kitbuilding or scratchbuilding would surely result in a bigger, uglier dog. I like the Hornby VEP. Now where did I put my white stick?

Edited by Pete 75C
  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

That porch effect with the connecting door being deeply recessed looks horrendous. That has to be one of the biggest gaffs with this model, but the blinkered seem to be ignoring it. The 4VEP is still a Dog!

20 years ago, we had no EMUs to boot. You had either the 501 tin plate from Dublo, the Triang looks a bit like a southern EMU and even those were hard to find.

 

We then had the 466, Simon K never understood why this model, but it quickly boosted our aspirations, even if the model had realistic wheel slip for leaves on the line.

 

Then silence for almost 10 years, leaving to fight with metal kits, Kirk kits or at best southern pride. Today I am glad of all these EMUs even if the VEP is not up to cep standards, it is still better than nothing.

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

I have previously used MJT brass sides and driving ends on Lima mark 1 coach chassis, all motorised with a Lima class 73 motor bogie. It ran OK and looked the part in plain BR blue, but I never got around to adding all the door handles, grab rails, door hinges, and bump stops. I did eventually add silver window frames, using a silver gel pen ... wasn't that a tedious job!

No, the Hornby one has its faults, especially at full retail price, but at the reduced prices I have always paid, I can accept that the face is not right but the hard work of detailing and painting the complex sides is already done for me to a very high standard. The running qualities are not up to the Bachmann CEP/EPB/MLV standards but are not bad either, and a good deal better than my old Lima based unit. I have a spare Hornby motor bogie lined up for installation in the MJT/Lima unit eventually.

 

I'm certainly not saying everyone has to accept the shortcomings of the Hornby VEP, just that some of us are prepared to accept more compromise than others. Each to his own. :)

Edited by SRman
Link to post
Share on other sites

I cant really comment on the shades used as I still haven't seen the B/G model in the flesh yet and screen saturation has too many variables.

I'm happy with me Blue and NSE sets that I have as there actually very good runners. Guess I Must have been one of the lucky ones.

Dog Cat or any other animal you might want to refer it to, to the majority of us it looks like a VEP and that's good enough. improvements and mods are what modelling is all about after all

NOTHINGS PERFECT IF IT WAS WE'D HAVE NOTHING TO MOAN ABOUT. :laugh:

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

  • RMweb Premium

When I get time, I will paint the yellow bits on the inside edge of the gangway black, and also pick out the black (dirt) line on the outside, comparing the two images above, there is too much yellow around the gangway area which highlights the incorrect depth even more.

 

The blue grey vep runs much better than my NSE, so with the above, it is for me, more than acceptable.

  • Like 3
Link to post
Share on other sites

It is nice to see the correct interior in the driving trailers. Unfortunately the motor coach of my model has a lighting bar for the rebuilt Vep, and an interior and stepboards to match that version. Again, no guard irons despite being shown on the picture on the box.

But as said earlier it is good times for emu modellers at present and it would be boring if there was nothing to add or modify on a model. 

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

WOW incredible response from Kernow, ordered a VEP and BIL weds eve and they both turned up this morning!

 

MUCHOOS GRACIAS

 

So far only test run but first impressions are that  the VEP is incredibly smooth with excellent slow speed control easily as good as the 2-BIL'S & 5-BEL.

When I've had a chance to run it in I'll report back but if its as good a runner as it looks to be, I'll be fitting the upgraded power bogie to my other 2 VEP'S.

 

Thanks Hornby

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • RMweb Premium

Today I collected my blue/grey example ex-Kernow from the sorting office.

 

Running wise, it's an improvement on their previous batch, the motor ran better and cab end tension locks didn't bind on curves. However I found they inserted a plain wheelset that had a groove milled in so a traction tyre could be fitted on the trailing bogie of the motor coach, which caused a lot of noise when running.

Substituting that with a spare 14mm diameter non-grooved wheelset solved the matter.

 

post-850-0-13349900-1425139237_thumb.jpg

 

This is my second and almost certainly my last 4VEP in my fleet, so I now have the satisfaction of owning both original and refurbished versions in my preferred livery choices.

I haven't decided yet whether to renumber the blue/grey example in the 30XX or 31XX series and affix NSE markings, or to keep it as the original.

 

post-850-0-84233200-1425139254_thumb.jpg

 

I'll chip my unit which allows me to switch off the carriage lighting, and also address light bleed in and around the headcodes by painting the insides black and/or boxing in the light.

 

They are intended to be my workhorses in my collection as much as what happened on the Southern Region with the prototypes.

  • Like 3
Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...