Jump to content
 

Episode 11: "One Hundred and Eighty!"


Keith Addenbrooke

422 views

The last few blog posts have been about getting ready to move house.  I'm happy to say it has gone very well in many ways, and we are delighted to be in our new home.  But what has been the impact on my railway modelling?

 

Getting read to move - the rest of the story:

 

At the end of Episode 8, the rather pleasant  homework I set for myself was to read @James Hilton's excellent and imaginative Wild Swan books:

 

spacer.png

 

If you've not yet got copies, can I please recommend them - whether or not space is a constraint.  Every page paints a beautiful picture that shows just how uplifting our pastime can be.  Well worth having on the bookshelf.

 

It was nice to see some personal favourites I've come across in my (online) travels too, including the San Luis Central Railroad, the Matt Brewery in Utica (NY), the Claremont and Concord, and the Napoleon and Defiance.  It was also another chance to enjoy James' own layouts (I find Kinross inspirational).

 

One comment however stood out for me.  In noting the positive role train sets can play in the hobby, James writes "if you've got this far then I shall assume you're looking for something more."  I agree.  For me, taking a continuous run out of the modelling equation can feel like I'm somehow settling for less.  I like seeing trains run.

 

So, knowing space was going to be at a premium after our move, I found a fantastic deal online for an unopened train set, and bought it as a base from which I could build after the move.  Purely for fun, a PIKO DB ICE3 4-car set:

 

01TrainSet.jpeg.46846900415545e1c6bcd120c701d1e4.jpeg

 

02TrainSetset-up.jpeg.b3315bbd99588b52f902196a8ff365a8.jpeg

 

Now some will look at this and see half a train chasing its tail.  But I looked at it another way.  Calculating the length of a circuit and timing a few laps enabled me to work out the (scale) speed of the train - and how far it was travelling.  Even running-in at half-speed (plenty fast enough for those curves, thank you), I followed my train on a scale journey of almost forty miles in half an hour, before reversing it and watching it return: a round trip of nearly 80 miles!

 

Even without scenery, ballast or the other four coaches the train should have, I enjoyed it.  So much so that I went out and bought a strengthening coach to make it into a 5-car set (some newer ICE units can run as 5-car sets).   There is still fun to be had with a train set.  And it's not all toylike.  True, it wasn't very realistic (in many ways), but I was impressed with PIKO A-Track.  It is Code 100, so fine for my older Fleischmann stock, but has a much thinner railhead profile than PECO Code 100.  The chairs are also more finely detailed (not so clear in the photo below, sorry).  Looks to me like a good product.

 

Peco on the left, Piko on the right:

 

03PikoA-track.jpeg.d0d99776c790a87e2869ca6609db526c.jpeg

 

I thought I was all set; a stash of kits for after we move, and a train set to run trains on...  Then we moved.

 

One Hundred and Eighty!

 

I'd set myself a downsizing target of 100 boxes of 'stuff' to move for the family - based on the boxes in our last move.  So when the removal team - working incredibly hard in very hot weather - unloaded one hundred and eighty it was clear that whatever the target was supposed to mean, I'd missed it.  Big time: 80% over.  No nine dart finish to see here.

 

Downsizing is continuing, because it has to.  The proposed modelling space is nowhere to be seen, buried under pile of boxes and crates which have nowhere else to go.  Of course, all the practice I had building baseboards at the last house is coming in handy in other ways:

 

04CoatHooks.jpeg.e1ff671899cd73f19c018cd7c89a5fc9.jpeg

 

But I need to think again about how much space I can expect to have.  When I previously shared this next photo it was supposed to show how I'd cut back on the number of buildings I was going to take with me:

 

spacer.png

 

Now it just reminds me how much I had under the tables! 

 

There was always a chance some model buildings might not enjoy the move, but the bag of bits I've collected is not large:

 

06SpareBits.jpeg.f86b8f40865bb9394f5d69458718c16b.jpeg

 

Damage was sustained by some part-finished platform and awning sections, with twelve of the sixteen supports breaking:

 

05PlatformPieces.jpeg.36e59138cf39309b3fc70bd8bddea30d.jpeg

 

But I suppose it is a kind of compliment - they must have looked much more substantial than they were!

 

Other damage is not down to the move - such as the warped sides of this scratchuilt HOn30 Combine I noticed when unwrapping it - more internal support needed next time:

 

07CombineSides.jpeg.169efc9637699909b02617cff7e4a6b6.jpeg

 

And I've had enough of cutting rows of roof tiles from a reel for an American Craftsman Kit I've part-built - it had been paused for months already with the fiddly bits still to do.  I have plenty of other kits I'd rather be getting on with instead:

 

08ChurchRoof.jpeg.16cd2ad148b460aa5b6d90d5aeccf3de.jpeg

 

Those are bits and pieces.  What is the 'big idea' going to be now?

 

A 'little bit' of Temptation to resist

 

It only takes a mild case of temptation to get me going.  This time it has come in the form of Bachmann's new NG7 range .  

 

I've been thinking about O-Scale narrow gauge for a while, with Bachmann's North American On30 range also appealing.  The trains are not a problem (certainly not when compared with mainline H0), but the size of everything else around them is what takes up the space.  I noticed 1:43 was stamped on the bottom of an MGA I was unwrapping, so I compared it to a couple of 4mm Scale OO cars I had to hand:

 

09ScaleCars.jpeg.31e45ad70247c2e78b117246b5f5c694.jpeg

 

While I was still keen to inspect the Bachmann NG7 Quarry Hunslets at our local 009 Society Group meeting last weekend, I was able to come away wallet unopened for once.  The test had worked!  But do check out NG7 - for any fan of Narrow Gauge modelling, the models look and, from what I've seen so far, run superbly.  A lovely new range from Bachmann.

 

Creative downsizing

 

Back to the story.  Having resisted the temptation to try something new, it's time for some creative downsizing instead.  The train set might be fun, but without space it's not something I can build around.  I still have more buildings than I have room for (with a crate load of kits queued up behind them, including the large Faller Neustadt building a yard long).

 

So what I've done is put together a book of photos I've taken while modelling over the past few years.  I've used a website called 'Snapfish' which other family members use for holiday trip photos and the like: why not use it for my own models too?  I'd rather keep the models, but a proper book of memories will be a good substitute I can look at any time instead.  It will also take up a lot less space than a grain elevator, or another mainline station:

 

10GrainElevator.jpeg.abb66fd54dd663e976f438397eb5e83c.jpeg

 

13ICE3atOstermundigen.jpeg.b31d2f7296aee14c61c7eb02a981114f.jpeg 

'Stuff' will then go.  Some for sale, some to the tip, and some donated to the local model railway club.

 

What happens next?

 

The more space I can clear, the easier the way forward will be.  I'll use the summer to re-read James' Hilton's books, and a few others, then hopefully be back in a month with a new plan.  We could be living here for the next fifteen years, and with the house coming with my job, there won't be any plans for extensions, loft conversions or large garden sheds (the garden is small).  I need to fit my ideas to the space - which is something we all have to do, but I've not proved to be very good at!

 

What I do know is that all the experimenting I did at our last home should now pay off: there are a host of ideas I don't need to explore, because I've looked at them already!  As long as I think small, it means I have a clean slate once more.

 

And that, for an imagineer like me, is always going to be exciting.  So, until then, do enjoy your summer, and thank you as always for reading thus far, Keith.

 

Edited by Keith Addenbrooke

  • Like 1
  • Friendly/supportive 6

7 Comments


Recommended Comments

Keith, I do wonder if you have considered writing on a blog site rather than just on here - because I think people would enjoy finding your writing, and journey, and it’s a long form style that works well. Just an idea.

 

Thank you for the kind words RE the books, third on the way shortly (in print as I type this)… but your quote made me think about my original intent…

 

I think you’ve slightly misquoted me - because I think I’d also say that I totally see the draw of a trainset. I even bought another one this year… but the books subject is beyond that, that is all…. But thank you, because you made me think again about the book, the subject and my intention.

 

Best of luck in the new place!

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment

Keith,

 

Another great post. Insightful and thoughtful as always. I completely echo James' thoughts above. I think you've got a real gift for writing. I follow you on NGRM and also here (since I've started partaking in RM Web after a long hiatus). The way you convey things is excellent (perhaps reflective of the day job!?!)

 

I'll be very interested to follow your next move. I have always modelled in 009, but I fancy trying something to run alongside that. I'm currently flitting between ideas in N Gauge and TT120, so I've found your recent thoughts interesting. 

 

Anyway I'll stop waffling now. I'm delighted your move has went well and I hope you settle into your new home soon. 

 

Thanks as always for sharing.

David 🙂 

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Premium
8 hours ago, James Hilton said:

Keith, I do wonder if you have considered writing on a blog site rather than just on here - because I think people would enjoy finding your writing, and journey, and it’s a long form style that works well. Just an idea.

 

Thank you for the kind words RE the books, third on the way shortly (in print as I type this)… but your quote made me think about my original intent…

 

I think you’ve slightly misquoted me - because I think I’d also say that I totally see the draw of a trainset. I even bought another one this year… but the books subject is beyond that, that is all…. But thank you, because you made me think again about the book, the subject and my intention.

 

Best of luck in the new place!


Thank you for your kind and thoughtful response, as always.
 

For anyone who wants to check out James’ full quote with regards to train sets it’s on page 10 of the second book, “The Art of Railway Modelling.”  I have slightly edited the paragraph in my post above to acknowledge the more positive tone of the original words - which is as James explains above.  Thanks, Keith.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Premium
5 hours ago, south_tyne said:

Keith,

 

Another great post. Insightful and thoughtful as always. I completely echo James' thoughts above. I think you've got a real gift for writing. I follow you on NGRM and also here (since I've started partaking in RM Web after a long hiatus). The way you convey things is excellent (perhaps reflective of the day job!?!)

 

I'll be very interested to follow your next move. I have always modelled in 009, but I fancy trying something to run alongside that. I'm currently flitting between ideas in N Gauge and TT120, so I've found your recent thoughts interesting. 

 

Anyway I'll stop waffling now. I'm delighted your move has went well and I hope you settle into your new home soon. 

 

Thanks as always for sharing.

David 🙂 


Hi David, thank you for your kind words as well.  
 

Having dabbled in both N and TT:120 over the past couple of years I found plenty to enjoy in both.  Although the difference in scale is not large I think it does give TT:120 something different to offer, which is interesting.  009 has also changed massively with the advent of plenty of r-t-r in recent years of course, adding another dimension there too.

 

Thanks again, Keith.

  • Friendly/supportive 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Premium

As an addendum, in my post above I make the following comment (near the top):

 

"knowing space was going to be at a premium after our move, I found a fantastic deal online for an unopened train set, and bought it as a base from which I could build after the move"

 

What did I have in mind?  This promotional video made by the Noch company in 2018 shows one way to develop what is basically the same simple track plan into a scenic working diorama / layout.  Tunnels are used to hide the end curves, which visually helps create the impression that the rear line could be a different route altogether, rather than hiding it behind a backscene.  While it is a project to showcase Noch's new offerings, this video (only available in German) shows how the multi-level scenery is built up - it is not just a table top circuit.  Thanks, Keith. 

 

 

 

Edited by Keith Addenbrooke
  • Like 2
Link to comment
  • RMweb Premium

Hi Keith. 

As ever its a pleasure to read another of your blog posts. 

 

And I do sympathise with the number of excess boxes. Some 20 years ago my new neighbours helped move my "excess luggage" into the loft; it's been there ever since awaiting my attention! 

 

Obviously the main issue is to find an identifiable place for a layout. And a continuous run is a recurrent theme in your musings. But equally working in the smaller scales can be challenging. 

 

With that in mind I'd be tempted to go down the freelance OO9 route. I've recently spent some happy hours reading up on various OO9 layouts which might fit the bill.

 

It'd have the advantage that track laying would be minimal. Whereas buildings would be at 4mm. 

 

You could also keep the scene neutral allowing for any variety of the new R-T-R offerings. You could even swap between UK and continental buildings to mix things up. 

 

I had a look at the new 7mmNG yesterday but, for me, they didn't add that much cf their 4mm stablemates.

 

Cheers. Andy

 

 

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Premium
Northroader

Posted (edited)

Hope you’re settling in well. With my recent move I really had to downsize in a hurry, with the need to declutter the house for prospective buyers, (though we still ain’t sold the place, a year on!) and things had to go tout suite. Maybe if you can offload from your new base, it will be done in a more orderly and leisurely manner.

I'm not knocking the Intercity, probably the line of mine that saw the most action was a roundy roundy, although there was a steam engine with outside valve gear involved, which gave a very pleasant relaxation just sitting and watching.

Enjoy the next round of planning and building.

Bob.

Edited by Northroader
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...